Polly: Which MI2 island would you live on?

September 27th, 2010 by | 7 comments

51% would prefer to do time in the jail on Phatt Island. I personally would prefer the one on Flotsam Island. Sure, it might get cold and windy, but at least I’d have something to look at. I think I would be bored to Murray if I had to spend years in the Phatt Island jail 🙂 This week we look only at the islands featured in Monkey Island 2. (Where the population is higher than 1.) Where would you choose to settle down? A cousy and dark island with an interesting town such as Scabb, a festive location with a costume shop like Booty, or a relaxed place with a library such as Phatt ?

Polly: Which MI2 island would you live on?

  • Scabb Island (28%, 21 Votes)
  • Booty Island (53%, 40 Votes)
  • Phatt Island (20%, 15 Votes)

Total Voters: 76

Loading ... Loading ...
Posted in Polly

7 Responses to “Polly: Which MI2 island would you live on?”

  1. Haggis says:

    Phatt, hands down. Sure, the governor may be a weird guy, but that library does it for me. A beautiful tropical island, and always enough to read? (Assuming that shipments of books arrive regularly.) Sign me up!

    • Dalixam says:

      Even if there’s no shipments it will take you a while to get through all the books 🙂 I chose Booty though, but I assume you can send me some books from Phatt? I can send you a few costumes in return… and a used coffin 🙂

      • Haggis says:

        Sounds like a deal! I want the Max costume, please. And that coffin will come in handy for when I assassinate Governor Phatt… but don’t tell anyone about that.

  2. Hande says:

    “Oh I’d rather be a pirate on Scabb,
    than a scab on a pirate.
    And if ya listen to me gab,
    I’ll tell ya why I admire it.”

    I think Scabb is one of the coolest islands in the entire series. The shipwreck town of Woodtick, the Swamp, the Graveyard. If only Rapp Scallion hadn’t blown himself up I might even enjoy the occasional hotdog, but Scabb is still my favorite by far. =D

  3. haydenwce27 says:

    Yeah, I’d say Scabb. To be a resident of Woodtick and part of it’s community would be an incredible thing. Sure there’s no library, and there’s no parties, but you can always go to the Voodoo Lady for information and help, and who needs parties when you can sit around a campfire for hours with Bart and Fink? Also, it’s not as though you’ll be stuck on the island, because all it takes is 20 pieces o’ eight to rent yourself a ride outta there and visit the surrounding islands. Plus, even if you can’t afford Captain Dread’s services, then you can always look at Wally’s maps and “you can see the whole world without even leaving your living room”.

  4. Harris McMahon says:

    I chose Scabb, but I will have to say I didn’t think too much about it, or else I would probably choose Phatt. However, I DO think that Scabb Island has the best music in the game. (Especially the Woodtick theme variations.) Therefore, if I would live there, it would probably have the best musicians of all three islands.

Leave a Reply